O’Reilly opened the show by highlighting clips of MSNBC contributor Goldie Taylor and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi accusing Romney of wanting to get booed by the NAACP. O’Reilly made it clear no such assertions were coming from anyone in the Obama campaign, but said it was “innuendo” and a strong theme coming from the “left wing.”
Shelton told O’Reilly that he could not say for sure if that was Romney’s motivation, but he could not rule it out as a possibility. He said that many people in the NAACP audience were “offended” by the way Romney laid out his position on the Affordable Care Act because of the millions of African-Americans who weren’t insured before the law passed. O’Reilly said that wasn’t what Taylor and Pelosi claimed, namely that Romney “antagonized” the crowd on purpose.
Shelton told O’Reilly he agreed completely with that assessment. He insisted that Republican candidates who have spoken to the NAACP in the past have not gotten the kind of reception Romney did, which O’Reilly heavily disputed. Shelton told O’Reilly that was an “untrue” statement.
O’Reilly accused Shelton of wanting Mitt Romney to pander to the African-American crowd instead of being honest about what he believes. Shelton dismissed the idea that Romney wanted to reach out to African-Americans, suggesting he could have at least tailored his message a little to the audience. Shelton attacked Romney’s position on education spending, to which O’Reilly lit into him and said outright that Shelton was lying.