Boston Mayor Apologizes: Long Overdue Justice for Wrongly Accused Black Men in 1989 Murder Case

On Wednesday, Boston Mayor Michelle Wu issued an apology that she deemed as "long overdue" to two Black men who were unjustly accused of the murder of a pregnant white woman in the year 1989. 

In the case of the tragic killing of Carol Stuart during a carjacking incident on October 25, 1989, the Boston police focused their investigation on the Black community and erroneously associated Alan Swanson and Willie Bennett with the crime. This misguided approach stemmed from the information provided by Charles Stuart, who claimed that a Black man wearing a track suit was responsible for the shooting. The unfortunate turn of events occurred when the woman passed away the following morning, and her newborn baby, who was delivered through a cesarean section, tragically passed away after 17 days. On January 4, 1990, Charles Stuart tragically took his own life. This event occurred shortly after his brother had approached the police with a startling revelation. It was revealed that Stuart had committed the heinous act of murdering his wife in order to obtain a substantial life insurance payout. In an attempt to divert suspicion away from himself, Stuart had also inflicted a gunshot wound to his own stomach.

At a press conference held at City Hall on Wednesday, Wu expressed the purpose of the gathering as an opportunity to recognize and address the significant suffering endured by Black residents in various neighborhoods of Boston 34 years ago. 

According to the Boston Globe, the mayor was accompanied by Swanson, various members of Bennett's family, and Boston police Commissioner Michael Cox. Wu expressed her apologies to Mr. Swanson, Mr. Bennett, the entire Bennett family, and the Black community in Boston for the hardships they had to face. The individual expresses sincere remorse for the enduring pain that the recipient has carried over an extended period of time. The actions taken against you were deemed unjust, unfair, racist, and morally incorrect.

According to the AP, Cox expressed apologies on behalf of the police department for their actions, which included a subpar investigation, excessive behavior, and actions that potentially violated the constitution. 

Following the occurrence of the murder, law enforcement authorities initiated a "stop-and-frisk campaign" specifically aimed at Black men residing in the Mission Hill neighborhood of the city. Additionally, the initial two detectives assigned to the case were removed from their duties, as they harbored immediate skepticism regarding Stuart's account of events. During the investigation conducted by the Globe, it was discovered that a total of 33 individuals had knowledge of Stuart's involvement in the murder of his wife. This information came to light when Stuart's brother, Matthew, who admitted to being an accomplice, eventually approached the police.



 

Get latest news delivered daily!

We will send you breaking news right to your inbox

© 2024 Wayne Dupree, Privacy Policy